PDA

View Full Version : X-MEN UNLIMITED #34 REVIEW


Brian Wilkinson
Apr 4, 2002, 05:17 pm
<a href="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/xmunl-34.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/xmunl-34t.jpg" align=left alt="X-Men Unlimited #34"></a>Reviewer: Brian E. Wilkinson, bewilkinson@yahoo.ca
Quick Rating: Good

Jubilee and Skin cut loose in L.A., Emma finds adventure in Monte Carlo, and Sunfire fights for the honour of his family!

Cover by: Christina Chen with UDON

Story #1 Title: ”My Name In Lights”
Written by: Ken Siu-Chong
Pencilled by: Christina Chen with Jo Chen
Colors by: TR2
Letters by: Randy Gentile

Story #2 Title: ”Underground”
Written by: Steven Grant
Pencilled by: Trevor Von Eeden
Colors by: Steve Oliff & Avalon Studios
Letters by: Randy Gentile

Story #3 Title: ”Twisted Sisters”
Written by: Karl Kesel
Pencilled by: James Fry
Colors by: Matt Milla & Avalon Studios
Letters by: Randy Gentile

For my two cents, X-Men Unlimited has always been one of those titles that I frequently alternate between loving and hating. The past few issues weren’t really that great (though each had highlights that made it worth the money) but I have this unshakable faith in the X-Machine that something great was just waiting to come out.

I’m not sure if #34 was exactly what I was hoping for, but I definitely enjoyed it. The first story “My Name In Lights,” was immediately my favorite as it featured Skin and Jubilee (two members of the recently cancelled series, Generation X) and I was very excited to get caught up on what they were up to in L.A. While the story didn’t deliver ALL the details of that trip (including the how and why that Jubilee came to join Banshee in the X-Corps storyline currently underway in Uncanny X-Men) or what Skin’s current status is, we do get a fairly believable story featuring the dysfunctional duo.

The story centers around Jubilee and her desire to make it in Hollywood as an actress. Though she has never expressed this desire before, her attitude and personality certainly don’t make it a stretch that she might choose to make it a career. Skin, for the most part, takes his typically cynical view of Jubilee and her chances of making it but his opinion is often shot down by Jubilee who mentions that Skin is currently flipping burgers at a fast-food chain. Throughout the story, we get to see Jubilee type-cast in Asian roles that have her acting like “Sailor June”, fighting Godzilla, appearing in a rap video, and finally as an Asian prostitute. Despite Angelo’s warnings that she is likely being used, Jubilee’s desire for stardom takes her deeper and deeper until she does indeed find herself being used. Someone should have warned Kristoff, a producer, of her temper as she lashes out and destroys the set after he attempts to take advantage of her.

So, what are the good and the bad here? Well, the good is that not only do we get to see more of these characters, but also that writer Ken Siu-Chong includes the fact that they are staying at one of Emma Frost’s (the White Queen currently featured in New X-Men) L.A. based homes. Ken delivers a solid story that portrays the seedy side of Hollywood with the undercurrent of racism that Jubilee experiences as a result of her acting jobs. The racism in this story is so subtly represented that one might overlook it, and I think Siu-Chong deserves a lot of credit for writing it in such a way that people can be aware of it. Not all racism is right in your face where you can see it and often it is the more subtle kinds that people experience on a daily basis. As for the bad, it mainly comes in that I don’t get to see more of these two characters and the other adventures I’m sure they had during their time in L.A.

The art by Christina Chen and Jo Chen is very well done and fits in beautifully with the type of story being told here. The downside is that shifts are often made in the style from the straightforward ‘realistic’ approach to Japanese-style drawing with large mouths and tears shooting out from the heads. I don’t have a problem with either style, but the mix was sometimes distracting. In the context of the story, however, the two styles DID work well. The colours, tones, and backgrounds were all done beautifully and I hope to see more from this duo in the future. In short, this was a great story about friendship, and a cautionary tale about the trappings of racism.

The next story, “Twisted Sisters” features the White Queen taking a vacation of sorts in beautiful Monte Carlo. On her arm at the beginning of the story is the coyly named “Bruce Gotham” (if you don’t get the Batman reference then shame on you!) and it seems Emma is up to her usual mind games as Brucie-baby is more than willing to do anything that she wants! Everything is going fine until Emma’s sister, Adrienne pops up to ruin the fun! Last seen in the final issues of Generation X Adrienne was seemingly shot to death by her own sister. A brief exchange of dialogue and Adrienne vanishes… was she really there or is Emma going crazy?

I must say that I really enjoyed this story. Karl Kessel not only gives readers an impromptu Generation X reunion but also nicely wraps up one of the biggest plot danglers from the final days of the series. I remember watching Emma ruthlessly killing her own sister and wanting to read on to see what this would mean in regards to her future role with both Generation X and the X-Men themselves. If they knew the truth about her, that she tried to kill her own sister, would she still be welcome in the fold. This is easily one of the most compelling stories I’ve read in X-Men Unlimited in a long time and I hope it’s indicative of what we can come to expect from the series.

The downside of this issue comes when Emma claims that Adrienne is responsible for killing her original students, the Hellions. I have NO idea where this came from as Adrienne has only been around since about Generation X #9 and was barely into her teenage years. There has never been an established motive for her to have killed the Hellions, nor does Emma reason out to the readers how she came to this conclusion. Other than this hiccup, it’s a nice story about the memories that haunt us and leads in well to her debut in New X-Men #114.

As for the art, it has a very retro-feel to it. It captures a lot of the spirit and flare that comic book characters used to show in years past (not to mention the outrageous costumes). The style is more than welcome with this reviewer, though I have to comment on the fact that Adrienne’s… assets… are a little overdone. Okay, a LOT overdone. Let’s just chalk that up to the charm of the story, shall we? I was also extremely pleased to see all the old Gen X team (including Emma) in their old uniforms. It’s the kind of colour and flare that (in my opinion) that the X-Men books are now missing. After all, what’s a super-hero but an immediately recognizable symbol of all that is good?

Just when I thought this issue was a Generation X reunion special, Sunfire (formerly of the X-Men) appears in a story by Steven Grant called “Underground.” It seems a cousin of Shiro’s has incurred a debt to a local drug dealer and his freedom can only be won if Sunfire agrees to complete a few tasks for the mobster. Shiro completes the task with the minimum amount of force needed and only kills when he must. In the end, the debt is repaid (and then some) and Shiro returns his cousin to his Aunt (in a manner of speaking).

A dark story with dark art and a dark ending which is kind of ironic considering Sunfire possesses the power of the sun itself. Blinding light, searing heat, and an undying flame all make Sunfire an imposing figure, yet it is the coldness of his heart which is by far the most striking image of this story. Sunfire has always been a character with a heart of stone. He has never been shown to have made friends with anyone in the X-Men, is a loner by nature, and has little to no social skills. Yet Grant also manages to show that he is a man of honour, despite his lack of talents in dealing with other people. His actions in this story are believable and that is what makes Sunfire all the more tragic. He saves the life of his cousin, yet in doing so takes the lives of several others.

Is he a hero or not? Was he EVER a hero for that matter? Grant makes the character ambiguous in this respect with enough evidence to prove Sunfire a hero or a villain. One thing is for sure, though, and that is that Grant has made Sunfire a character I want to learn more about. Sunfire is an under-used character with a ton of potential waiting to be explored. All we, the fans, can do is cross our fingers and hope… both for Sunfire’s return and for his redemption.

The art captures the mood of this story perfectly. The heavily layered dark tones contrast perfectly with the intense heat Sunfire displays making one wonder if it is Sunfire who has gone cold or the world around him. Though the art looks a bit basic in a few of the panels, it captures the same retro feeling shown in the “Twisted Sisters” story featured in this issue. I think artist Trevor Von Eeden shows a lot of potential here and I wouldn’t mind seeing more of his work in the future.

So, is this month’s issue of X-Men Unlimited worth your money? I’d have to say yes. In past months we’ve gotten vague or confusing stories that left me with little to no desire to revisit them. In this issue, we have not one, not two, but three fantastic stories that all give a deeper look into the characters we have all come to love over the years. If Marvel can keep this kind of quality up, then I’ll be sure to buy X-Men Unlimited each time it comes out!

Oh, last but not least, the pin-up at the back by Deodato featuring the New X-Men cast was great but Mike should have at least given Jean a shirt to wear!!! ;)

{I may be nitpicking, but if I don’t I resort to name-calling.}

Art:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xnone.jpg

Story:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xnone.jpg

Overall:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xnone.jpg

Buy this issue online now from X-World Comics (http://www.x-worldcomics.com/x/bstore/newbooksmain.html) and save!

Zachary Palisoc
Apr 4, 2002, 05:25 pm
Thanks for the review, although I'm still on the fence about this one. Not your fault, though. Your points and comments were clear enough. :)

-Z

Winston
Apr 4, 2002, 06:40 pm
Was the Wolverine and Rogue story for the series pushed back?

Brian Wilkinson
Apr 4, 2002, 06:54 pm
Yes, everything slated to appear in #34 has been put into issue #35. Conversely, the stories for #35 appear in this issue, #34.

Confusing to type, but basically they just traded up the issues for us.

Cobiatic
Apr 4, 2002, 07:35 pm
"I have NO idea where this came from as Adrienne has only been around since about Generation X #9 and was barely into her teenage years. "

Wasnt Adrienne her older sister and Cordelia her younger sister? And I believe Cordelia was in her teens.

Al Harahap
Apr 4, 2002, 10:45 pm
Originally posted by Brian E. Wilkinson
Oh, last but not least, the pin-up at the back by Deodato featuring the New X-Men cast was great but Mike should have at least given Jean a shirt to wear!!! ;)

I think it's Emma. The hair is blonde and her body is scantilly clad.

I agree with everything you said about the Jubes/Angelo story--I've heard many Jubes fans uproars about how trying out acting isn't in her character, but I don't think it's too far off, a girl needs to feed herself. The ending of that story made me remember why I liked Gen X so much.

Though I think you were far too kind on the Emma one. Other than the redeeming nostalgic qualities of the Gen X pseudo-flashbacks, it's just a mess IMO.

Anthony Zisa
Apr 4, 2002, 11:10 pm
Originally posted by Doop
I think it's Emma. The hair is blonde and her body is scantilly clad.

I thought that too, but I'm pretty sure Deodato said it was Jean when he originally drew it. I think it's just a coloring error.

Good review. I wasn't nearly as sweet on the issue as you were (I thought the White Queen story was rather subpar, with art that was way too cartoony for what the tone was), but I did enjoy the Steven Grant story quite a bit. Very dark, very nice, and the kind of neat little anthology bit that I want more of in this book -- not stuff to clear up plotholes, but moving character pieces.

The Jubilee/Skin story was fun, as well, but not nearly in the caliber of the Grant story (although the social commentary was more subtle and biting).

(The editing for this issue, however, as a bit sloppy. Grant appears to call his story "Underworld," but it's credited as "Underground," and the sequence of stories is off. Not huge gaffs, but I noticed them, and I don't usually pick up on this stuff.)

--acz

Brian Wilkinson
Apr 5, 2002, 12:23 am
Now I'M confused... I could have sworn that it was Cordelia (who WAS the younger sister) who killed Synch and was the one Emma killed...

oh well, no matter what sister it was that was a pretty useless story element overall. Make up one sister... make up another... bah. ;)

Still, in the context of the story (whomever it was) it was still well done.

Stochastic Fats
Apr 5, 2002, 03:05 am
no that was Adrienne who killed Synch in #65(?)
Cordelia was the first sister introduced in Gen X w/Mondo, beginning one of the worst sub-plots in the whole run. What the hell was Mondo supposed to be anyway? Some rip-off of "Grunge" that was stoned all the time?

Brian Wilkinson
Apr 5, 2002, 03:12 am
Let's just leave the past in the past and move on. It's better that way.


A moment of silence, please.

Vash_HS
Apr 5, 2002, 04:28 am
The concept of Mondo was good, the execution though was poor.

strangerx
Apr 5, 2002, 05:14 am
I usually stay away from the Unlimited book, but I might just pick this one up. Not only do I like Gen-X and Sunfire, but it actually sounds like a good read.

Plagioclase
Apr 5, 2002, 03:02 pm
I enjoyed the art from the Jubilee/Synch piece, but I wasn't moved by any of the stories.

Cobiatic
Apr 5, 2002, 04:20 pm
Originally posted by Stochastic Fats
no that was Adrienne who killed Synch in #65(?)
Cordelia was the first sister introduced in Gen X w/Mondo, beginning one of the worst sub-plots in the whole run. What the hell was Mondo supposed to be anyway? Some rip-off of "Grunge" that was stoned all the time?

It was in Gen-X #70 that she attempted to blow up the school, the people within and will...pretty much everyone. Ev and Sean managed to disable all the bombs but one, which was the one that Ev absorbed (?), killing him and saving everyone else. This is also the issue in which Emma apparently kills Adrienne.

Now I was looking back at #75 where it actually shows Emma killing Adrienne, only its just a dream/nightmare Emma is having. So now im wondering if Adrienne was truely killed?

Also, I thought maybe this might help in the defense of Adrienne apparently setting up the Hellions death. Back in issues 55 and 56 she organized a sort of reality wrapping device that put the Gen-Xers in the Hellions place during their ill-fated death. And the reality device was deadly, so she was basically trying to kill the "Hellions" aka Gen-X. And after they escaped from the generater thing thanks to Emma, Adrienne shows up dressed in the disguise of the New White Queen. She teleports away but I was just thinking maybe this could be what they are alluding to in the comic. :shrugs: oh well no use trying to piece this all together anyways.

Zachary Palisoc
Apr 5, 2002, 05:44 pm
Well, I got it. I liked the Jubes and White Queen stories. The art seemed a little werid for Jubliee, but that's probably because I still think of her with her sunglasses and that nifty cool yellow jacket.

Even though I had no knowledge about Gen X, the White Queen story wasn't that hard to figure out. That's a good thing. I didn't know who that guy was that got killed until I read this post.

I skipped the Sunfire part because I don't know him and it didn't look interesting, IMHO.

-Z

Mike Deodato Jr
Apr 6, 2002, 01:24 am
Originally posted by Anthony Zisa


I thought that too, but I'm pretty sure Deodato said it was Jean when he originally drew it. I think it's just a coloring error.



You're right! :)

Benjamin Ong
Apr 6, 2002, 01:38 am
Mike - Do you have the pinup online?

Wolverine
Apr 6, 2002, 02:47 am
I have said it once and I will say it again. This book is Irelivant and does not need to exist, It has nooooo Point.

Ferino
Apr 6, 2002, 09:38 am
Just a little bit of old trivia........but without diigging through the back issues didnt' a load of sentinels programmed by fitzroy kill the helions, in or around uncanny x-men 281?

apuyana
Apr 6, 2002, 12:12 pm
Yes, sentinels did kill emma's hellions, directed by fitzroy... it was through the whole upstart thing, they also hurt emma and jean, and that's the time where emma got into jeans mind...

Stochastic Fats
Apr 7, 2002, 05:04 am
Originally posted by xpawn
Mike - Do you have the pinup online?


http://fotos.terra.com.br/album.cgi/101973

silverboy
Apr 7, 2002, 04:53 pm
Cordelia Frost has only appeared in Gen X #3, 8 (I think), '95 Annual, 60 and 61, all issues having to do with Mondo. Andrienne Frost has appeared in or around Gen X #49-56, 67-70, attempting to manipulate and kill the team.

I don't know where the whole "Adrienne killed the Hellions" thing came from. I thought another story slightly concerning Synch was great, though, and partially necessary.

Cobiatic
Apr 7, 2002, 07:34 pm
Having read the ish now lemme just say it was really messed up. Im betting it was just Emma thinking Adrienne did or some weird thing like that. First off, Adrienne never wore that White Queen outfit during those scenes in Gen-X. Nor did Emma wear that Gen-X outfit. The story was full of editorial mistakes and I think it would have been better to have left that whole story the way it was left in Gen-X. The characterization for Emma was good but it would have been better if they actually paid attention to the story they were trying to retell.

Wolverine
Apr 8, 2002, 08:24 pm
Ah The many Continuity mistakes in this title. and there I was think it was out of fashion

Monolith
Apr 8, 2002, 09:01 pm
Originally posted by Cobiatic
Having read the ish now lemme just say it was really messed up. Im betting it was just Emma thinking Adrienne did or some weird thing like that. First off, Adrienne never wore that White Queen outfit during those scenes in Gen-X. Nor did Emma wear that Gen-X outfit. The story was full of editorial mistakes and I think it would have been better to have left that whole story the way it was left in Gen-X. The characterization for Emma was good but it would have been better if they actually paid attention to the story they were trying to retell.

Well, Emma DID say in narration that "nobody wore their costumes that night", but still I think it is a horrible retcon to try and say Adrienne had something to do with the Hellions deaths. If the writer of this story knew as much as that the Hellions WERE dead, wouldn't it have made sense to oh, I don't know....READ THE STORY WHERE THEY DIED?! Or at the very least acknowledge that a reversion was taking place? Reading this story in a vaccum, it sounds like the Hellions were mysteriously killed and Emma only now discovered how, and that simply wrong. :rolleyes:

Orphan
Apr 8, 2002, 10:52 pm
I have said it once and I will say it again. This book is Irelivant and does not need to exist, It has nooooo Point.

I agree with you. I think this book should be extinct and free some space to another x-title that would bring us something new. I´d like to see an x-corps title and a Nightcrawler ongoing series (altough I know it hasn´t any reason to exist right now as Kurt must be the most boring character in the X-universe at the moment... perhaps one day?).

Benjamin Ong
Apr 9, 2002, 12:45 am
Originally posted by Stochastic Fats



http://fotos.terra.com.br/album.cgi/101973

Thanks, Stochastic Fats. I've seen this before, Mike posted it online before :)

Eric J. Moreels
Apr 13, 2002, 05:39 am
Originally posted by Wolverine
I have said it once and I will say it again. This book is Irelivant and does not need to exist, It has nooooo Point.

And whilst your quite entitled to your opinion, it really does help make it a more credible one if you say why you think that.

I love X-Men Unlimited, because it gives fans a chance to see characters that we may not have seen for a while in stories by creators who you might not normally associate with work on an X-title.

Here's hoping it's around for a long, long time to come!

Eric J. Moreels
Apr 13, 2002, 05:44 am
Originally posted by Cobiatic
The story was full of editorial mistakes and I think it would have been better to have left that whole story the way it was left in Gen-X.

Um, you do realize that these were hallucinations and shaky memories of a traumatic event in Emma's life, and as such weren't meant to exactly portray in specific detail the events that Emma was reliving, don't you?

And because one of the events in question was so traumatic to her, you don't think it's possible that Emma's blaming Adrienne was a way to shift the blame from herself. That, to me, is true to Emma's character and a job well done by the writer.

Some of you really need to stop going into nitpick mode automatically as soon as you see something that contradicts past stories and really read the story to realize that it's not actually contradicting anything.

Monolith
Apr 13, 2002, 02:33 pm
Originally posted by X-Fan
Um, you do realize that these were hallucinations and shaky memories of a traumatic event in Emma's life, and as such weren't meant to exactly portray in specific detail the events that Emma was reliving, don't you?

And because one of the events in question was so traumatic to her, you don't think it's possible that Emma's blaming Adrienne was a way to shift the blame from herself. That, to me, is true to Emma's character and a job well done by the writer.

Some of you really need to stop going into nitpick mode automatically as soon as you see something that contradicts past stories and really read the story to realize that it's not actually contradicting anything.

I realize that could be true, Eric. In fact, that's exactly how I chose to view the story. But what about people who aren't "in the know"? They'll believe that Adrienne truly did kill off Emma's Hellions, and will be very confused the next time a non-hallucinagenic reference is made. At the very least, a footnote needed to be made stating how the Hellions really died, so that the full force of Emma's mental instability would be apparent.

TheJFan
Apr 20, 2002, 09:31 pm
Complete and total bunk, IMO.

I won't repeat myself as to why. Those thoughts are over on the X-Fan Features section, for those who have the inclination to hit it.

The story was ill conceived and in my mind made Jubilee seem like a Mary Sue for the author himself. The artwork was moderately enjoyable, however.

Thankfully, Jubilee's portrayal as the dominant personality of the X-Corps' Recon Group known as Banshee's Angels (anyone else catch the Gen-X Underground reference, folks? ;p) has been rather enjoyable. Admittedly, I, like other fans, am worried about whether or not she's going to be one of the casualties of the Group, or of the constant change in authors - especially since this.. horrid abberation with Fly Wings (Angel of New X-Men?) seems to have the same attitude J did when she first met X-Men, and appears to be encroaching on the same manner in which J worked with Wolverine as well. Hopefully those fears are completely unfounded.