BLACK PANTHER #43 REVIEW

[Erwin Rafael]

<a href="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/bpv3-43.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/bpv3-43t.jpg" align=left alt="Black Panther #43"></a>Reviewer: Erwin Rafael, 3rdsummers@edsamail.com.ph
Quick Rating: Excellent!
Story Title: The Kiber Chronicles (Enemy of the State II Book Three)

The pieces of T'Challa's complex puzzle start falling into place as Enemy of the State II continues.

Written by: Christopher Priest
Pencilled by: Sal Velluto
Inked by: Bob Almond
Lettered by: Dave Sharpe
Colored by: Jennifer Schellinger
Assistant Editor: Mike Raicht
Editor: Mike Marts
Editor-in-Chief: Joe Quesada
President: Bill Jemas

Sometimes, you have to dig really deep to strike gold.

Normally, I do not give a damn about Marvel "bottom wringers" - Marvel titles suffering at the bottom of the Top 100 - because I've read a lot of titles that DESERVE that status. Remember John Byrne's Spider Woman? Wild Thing? Fantastic Force? Machine Man? Darkhawk? Yeah, I know there are some of you who experience a guilty pleasure reading these titles, but really, just thinking about that Jay Faerber New Warriors series gives me shudders. :LOL:

Occassionaly, though, one may strike gold while digging through the bottom of the Top 100. Joe Casey and Leonardo Manco's Deathlok comes into mind. Mark Waid and Andy Kubert's Ka-Zar. Joseph Harris and Chriscross' Slingers. These are the Marvel "paradoxes" - books which receive much critical acclaim but sadly can not generate the sales figures they deserve.

Black Panther, for me, is Marvel's most puzzling paradox. As almost anybody frequenting a comic book news site knows, Black Panther has been suffering in sales for quite some time. Actually, it's the lowest-selling Marvel ongoing mainstream title, languishing in the bottom of the charts and occassionaly even falling out of the Top 100. Ironically, virtually all comic book reviewers agree that Black Panther is one of the best ongoing books Marvel puts out. Month in and month out, this book receives nothing but praise from respected authorities in the industry. Sadly, that praise rarely (if ever) translates into additional sales for the title.

This is my third issue of Black Panther, and I believe I have struck nothing but gold all three times. This issue highlights the creative team's versatility in handling different themes, tones and styles while managing to make it a coherent and attractive jumble of mess. If you thought that you can't mix humor, traditional superheroics, cool action sequences, satire, nostalgia, socio-political themes, quantum physics, over-the-top ridiculousness and college economics in a 22-page comic book story, you really have to see this book to believe that it can be done.

The issue in a flash. After last issue's confrontation, Iron Man went after Black Panther and Wolverine in an action-packed pursuit that took them to the depths of the Northern Atlantic. But Tony found himself outwitted again, as Black Panther took their fight to another battle-field - the business world - and took over Stark Enterprises with a simple phone call. Meanwhile, the nutty "Kirbyesque" Black Panther continued his quest to find King Solomon's Frog in the reemergent Kiber Island. And as an aside, Chante Giovanni Brown, aka Queen Divine Justice, debated health reform agendas with the President himself. The issue ends with a glimpse of the biggest threat to Earth - a small brass frog. No, I am not kidding :)

Guardian: ...do you really want war? You do realize the NATO implications?

Black Panther: I do Mr. Hudson, don't you? Just as I trust NATO realizes the Wakandan implications.

Black Panther used to be just another hero in the Marvel Universe. He was a traditional superhero with a funky set of technology who luckily happened to be a king. Christopher Priest, though, made the Panther stand out from the rest of the MU superheroes by tapping his unique attributes, exploiting in particular his status as a monarch. This issue showcased the Panther's distinct methodologies, fighting in the political as well as the business arena. I specially liked how he "beat" Tony Stark with a combination of espionage tactics and economic manipulations. It's a refreshingly distinct "T'Challa-style" of fighting.

Some quarters are saying that Christopher Priest's Black Panther has become the Marvel Universe's equivalent to Batman, which I think is a perfectly valid observation. Batman has been characterized as the most dangerous man alive in the DC Universe (particularly in Grant Morrison's JLA run). Despite not having superpowers, his brilliant calculating mind provides him the capability to beat just about anybody. Plus, he is a wildcard, preferring to work alone and not always in the interest of the JLA. Priest's Black Panther, I believe, has reached a similar status. Black Panther's concerns does not always jive with the Avengers' interests, and as this storyline showed, it can actually come into conflict as well. Priest also presented the Panther as a brilliant mind who always have four aces up his sleeve. I'd even hazard to say that Priest's Black Panther can beat just about any Avenger, just like how Batman has beaten every JLA member in the "Tower of Babel" storyline.

While I already found the main Black Panther-Iron Man-XCon conflict outstanding, my favorite running storyline in the book was still that of the "Kirbyesque" Black Panther. I remember that when Black Panther vol. 3 first came out, there was a dissension in the message boards from fans of the original Kirby Black Panther regarding Christopher Priest's version. I did some research on this, and I found that Jack Kirby's run in the first Black Panther series did present a Black Panther who was diametrically different personality-wise from Priest's Black Panther. At first, I thought that Priest's revival of the Kirby version was some sort of satirical answer to the dissenters, as if pairing the two versions of Black Panther would highlight the ridiculousness of the original. After reading this issue, though, I felt that what Priest may want to actually achieve was some sort of homage to the Kirby version. It felt like Priest was symbolically giving the Kirby version of the Black Panther a fitting sendoff before Priest's version fully take over. Priest even used Kiber Island as his setting this issue, which was also the setting of Jack Kirby's final Black Panther story, "Kiber the Cruel". Which is why despite the humorous situations the Kirby Panther went through this issue, I felt an air of sadness as we seemingly near our eventual farewell to Kirby's legacy.

The little subplot starring Queen Divine Justice was really humorous. While it did not contribute anything to the advancement of the main plot, Chante's debate with the President allowed Priest to showcase his strength with dialogue-based humor. It's a surreal scene, actually, and it did not make any sense yet as to whether this subplot would mean much in the long run. But what the heck?!!! It's still a good couple of pages of entertainment. I also noticed that the President has been making a lot of guest appearances in Marvel comic books lately. I wonder why? :LOL:

If there's any complaint I have with Priest's writing this issue, it's this scene where Iron Man was defeated underwater. Last issue, I commented that Priest got Tony Stark's character perfectly while he made Wolverine a bit too talkative. It's the other way around this issue. Iron Man explained ALOUD to Black Panther every technical detail of how Black Panther damaged his armor. It came across as an unnatural piece of dialogue, much like how Cyclops explained aloud his explanation of Jean's suicide in the "Dark Phoenix Saga".

This title is blessed to have the talented Velluto-Almond-Schellinger art team. Their work is capable of expressing a wide range of human emotions. I particularly liked how they depict Agent Everett Ross' facial expressions, which were enough to make me laugh. The art team also seamlessly juxtaposed the retro Kirby-style artwork with the more modern and realistic art style, perfectly reflecting the wild mix of different tones and themes in Priest's writing.

I could go on and on endlessly praising this title, but I do have to reserve some more for the next issue. I'm eagerly looking forward to see how King Solomon's Frog could become a big threat to an entire planet. And if you think I sound ridiculous with what I am saying, go read this issue and find out how a small brass frog can be taken seriously. Actually, the Black Panther comic is pretty much similar to King Solomon's Frog. They both look unimpressive at first glance, but they could actually pack a wallop. Now go and read your Black Panther!!!

Rating:

Art:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg

Story:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

Overall:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpg

Buy this issue online now from X-World Comics (http://www.x-worldcomics.com/x/bstore/newbooksmain.html) and save!

[Erwin Rafael]

i would like to thank this website for the information regarding Jack kirby's Black Panther:

Black Panther: Artistic Impressions (http://www.cgriffen.com/blackpanther/home.html)

be sure to visit that site because it's really informative ;)

[Eric J. Moreels]

I for one enjoyed Wild Thing (as did Sarah - it was pretty much the only Marvel title she's ever read on a monthly basis) and loved X-51. I also quite enjoyed Jay's New Warriors and thought it was cancelled far too early.

[Erwin Rafael]

ok. that was in jest actually. i almost made fun of NFL Superpro too :LOL:

so to everybody who may be hurt by what i said about those lower tier-titles, just take what i said lightly. it's a good natured ribbing. i for one, have to admit that i used to enjoy...:D nah, that would ruin my reputation ;)

[stormwatch]

Okay, I haven't done my review yet. But I would like to say that this is a simpler context of the the arc so far. I haven't read the issue again, although I will tonight, for my review.

And heather Hudson being pregnant, nice touch, only recently revealed in Wolverine 173. Very nice touch.

And, well, before i say anything definite, I think this issue was more of a tie in. It helps tie stuff in, not as much as the final issue, but still, it goes with the run of this arc. I'll be able to say more when I'm done, but otherwise, good review.

And I've been doggedly pursuing the back issues. They are entertaining. Just got finished The Client tpb, and well, it was great, and another 5 issue arc. NOw I'll see if I can break down Priests 5 issue arc right now.

Issue 1: Goes about setting up the run. Although confusing, but leaves you wanting.
Issue 2: Same as issue 1, but goes more in depth and leaves the reader even more curious and confused. More of the former than the latter though, for me at least.
Issue 3: THis is the issue that starts plugging some of the holes, and lessening the confusion, but increasing the curiousity. If you can get up to the third issue in the arc, you will get the fourth issue.
Issue 4: This issue, adds a bit more in confusion, stirs the pot, and makes sure that all the ingredients are somewaht placed. Unfortuantely, it is still a bit confusing, but is also the issue to make you get the fifth.
Issue 5: NOw this one ties the knot on the whole arc, and sets up for the next. The confusion ends here, but the curiousity is still strong. Usually, after you read the fifth issue, you are either commited to the character or you are not.

NOw that is my little breakdown for now. And Erwin, although I've read half of your review so far, I like it, although, that is from first impression, and I think, well, overall it was, well, debateable. I've heard some people say that Stark was talking way too much, explaining to the reader everything. And I was kind of puzzled with the frogs. ALthough the frogs now I am curious about, and also liked it more after reading the Trade TPB The Client.

THe Frogs, at first glance, it seems trivial, I thought so myself, but they are not. Its just a ploy before we see their true power I am guessing. THis could be interesting, although I will post again after my review fo course.

Later,
Stormie

[strangerx]

I'm just curious if the start of this arc might be a good jumping on point for a new reader?

I'm interested in picking this book up, but don't know where to start.

[stormwatch]

Originally posted by strangerx
I'm just curious if the start of this arc might be a good jumping on point for a new reader?

I'm interested in picking this book up, but don't know where to start.

yes it would be, if you could find them, they are already sold out where I frequent, but if you can find them, I suggest you get them without delay. Retailers don't order enough of them, so grab them while you can.

[Vash_HS]

Yes it is, but definitly pick up the client and Enemy of the state 1 tpbs as well (cause they're really good).

[Erwin Rafael]

Originally posted by stormwatch82
Okay, I haven't done my review yet. But I would like to say that this is a simpler context of the the arc so far. I haven't read the issue again, although I will tonight, for my review.

yeah, read the issue again. this is one of the books where you get something new as you read it over and over :D


And I've been doggedly pursuing the back issues. They are entertaining.

i myself am starting to collect the back issues, but in reverse order. i just completed the "Return of the Dragon" arc and it's good. not as good as EOTS 2, though. :D


NOw that is my little breakdown for now. And Erwin, although I've read half of your review so far, I like it, although, that is from first impression, and I think, well, overall it was, well, debateable. I've heard some people say that Stark was talking way too much, explaining to the reader everything. And I was kind of puzzled with the frogs. ALthough the frogs now I am curious about, and also liked it more after reading the Trade TPB The Client.

hey, i commented on that Stark talking too much thing!!! that scene made me squint :LOL:

what do you think of the Batman comparison i made? my brother told me that out of the blue and i saw a lot of people commenting that, and i agree with them. i'm talking though, of the JLA Morrison and Waid Batman, where he is the most dangerous JLA member ever :D

THe Frogs, at first glance, it seems trivial, I thought so myself, but they are not. Its just a ploy before we see their true power I am guessing. THis could be interesting, although I will post again after my review fo course.

i really like Priest's weird humor - assigning enormous power on a brass frog. LOL but as my research proved, the lunacy of his Black Panther is nothing compared to the Kirby original series. i really am curious why the Sixth Man (what is that villain called again) has Hatch 22 on his forehead :LOL:

[stormwatch]

Originally posted by Erwin Rafael


yeah, read the issue again. this is one of the books where you get something new as you read it over and over :D

Yes you do, and I'll go into a bit of depth in a bit.

i myself am starting to collect the back issues, but in reverse order. i just completed the "Return of the Dragon" arc and it's good. not as good as EOTS 2, though. :D

Well, I find that there are some issues that if you see them, get them, like the Deadpool crossover, and Ororo, but I can't find the Return of the Dragon, in its completion right now.


hey, i commented on that Stark talking too much thing!!! that scene made me squint :LOL:

Well, after reading the first 14 issues, I don't mind Stark and Wolverine talking so much. Especially since Ross is usually there to do it. And it has somewhat changed from the first issues, but to get a good understanding of Ross, read the two trades, they are funny.

what do you think of the Batman comparison i made? my brother told me that out of the blue and i saw a lot of people commenting that, and i agree with them. i'm talking though, of the JLA Morrison and Waid Batman, where he is the most dangerous JLA member ever :D

The Batman comparison is great, and I managed to get a hold of issue 30, which shows that Black Panther could also be compared to Namor or the like of Kings. But the Batman, well, It fits so well, but I like Black Panthers gadgets a little more, cince they are fewer, but are more variable, which is nice.


i really like Priest's weird humor - assigning enormous power on a brass frog. LOL but as my research proved, the lunacy of his Black Panther is nothing compared to the Kirby original series. i really am curious why the Sixth Man (what is that villain called again) has Hatch 22 on his forehead :LOL:

Priests weird humour is great. Fabulous. And the Brass Frog, well, my first reaction was just like Wolverines, its a trinket, and that rolled around to the point where its now, oh my, talk about an april fools joke, I am still dumbfounded over it. But it was great.

But I find its hard getting a complete arc in one place. But I know the Trades are selling great in some of the places I frequent.

[Tommy Boy]

I keep on considering picking BP up, but a combination of the art and the complicated plot keep throwing me off but it is starting to appeal to me more but i lost my frickin' job recently so my comic book buying is on a temporary hiatius until i find work again. Damn is that annoying... :mad:

[Erwin Rafael]

Originally posted by Tommy Boy
I keep on considering picking BP up, but a combination of the art and the complicated plot keep throwing me off but it is starting to appeal to me more but i lost my frickin' job recently so my comic book buying is on a temporary hiatius until i find work again. Damn is that annoying... :mad:

hey, hope you get a job soon. btw, if you're looking for a nice issue to jump on to, start with the new storyline, SADDLES ABLAZE. it begins with issue 46 shipping June 26. you might even win something (http://geocities.com/saveblackpanther) ;)

[Toño Anaya]

Originally posted by Erwin Rafael


hey, hope you get a job soon. btw, if you're looking for a nice issue to jump on to, start with the new storyline, SADDLES ABLAZE. it begins with issue 46 shipping June 26. you might even win something (http://geocities.com/saveblackpanther) ;)

Erwin, I'll be honest. I haven't read a single issue of Black Panther...but you've sold me on the idea of checking it out. I'll pick up the latest tomorrow. :)

-Toño

[Tommy Boy]

Originally posted by Erwin Rafael


hey, hope you get a job soon. btw, if you're looking for a nice issue to jump on to, start with the new storyline, SADDLES ABLAZE. it begins with issue 46 shipping June 26. you might even win something (http://geocities.com/saveblackpanther) ;)

Thanks dude. I had an interview which went quite well so i'm hoping it won't be too long till i get back into my favourite habit!!

I am looking forward to seeing how dangerous those brass frogs really are.... That Christopher Priest.... :rolleyes: :D :) :D ;)

[Erwin Rafael]

Originally posted by Toño


Erwin, I'll be honest. I haven't read a single issue of Black Panther...but you've sold me on the idea of checking it out. I'll pick up the latest tomorrow. :)

-Toño

Black Panther 44 is coming out this week. that's part 4 of the 5-part Enemy of the State 2 story arc. i suggest that you either a) track down issues 41-43 to get the complete picture of the storyline, or b) wait for the start of the next story arc, Saddles Ablaze, starting with issue 46 shipoping June 26. preorder that issue now because the order cutoff date is June 6.

[Brandon Yates]

Loved this issue (so what else is new?). This whole storyline has been much better than I expected (I was a little wary of a Wolverine guest appearance) and I loved the bit about T'Challa taking over Stark Enterprises with a single phone call.

Some people are annoyed by BP's being 2,342 steps ahead of everyone but, to me, that's his "power." I mean, come on, the guy's a king of a small African nation with some of the most technologically advanced devices on the planet (and don't forget the vibranium). With the U.S., Russia, and every other nation wanting to get their hands on your resources you HAVE to be at least 2,342 steps ahead of them to survive.

He's not a superhero. He's a king. And this book is proving just what it takes to be a king in the Marvel Universe.