PDA

View Full Version : ULTIMATES #4 REVIEW


Anthony Zisa
May 3, 2002, 10:07 pm
<a href="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/ultimates-04.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/covers/ultimates-04t.jpg" align=left alt="Ultimates #4"></a>Reviewer: Anthony Zisa, PopinFrsh@aol.com
Quick Rating: Excellent!
Story Title: Thunder

Tensions within the team flare as questions about their usefulness arise. Meanwhile, Nick Fury and Bruce Banner attempt to recruit the God of Thunder, and Betty Ross gets a dangerous phonecall!

Written by: Mark Millar
Penciled by: Bryan Hitch
Inked by: Andrew Currie
Lettered by: Chris Eliopoulos
Colored by: Paul Mounts
Associate Editors: C.B. Cebulski & Brian Smith
Editor: Ralph Macchio
Editor-in-Chief: Joe Quesada
President: Bill Jemas

It has been four months into the run of The Ultimates, and nothing has essentially happened, save the building of the team. Little in the way of “action” has occurred since the pulse-pounding debut issue.

And the book is all the better for its lack of “action.” In fact, lack of action would be a misnomer when referring to Mark Millar’s first storyline. There’s so much going on within the book at the moment that unnecessary fights would ruin the wonderful rhythm Millar has established. Millar, during his Authority tenure, was accused of eschewing character development in favor of wall-to-wall action and over-the-top violence. The Ultimates reads as a reaction against those accusations – with wall-to-wall characterization and over-the-top development of the team dynamic, The Ultimates is the anti-Authority. The team’s internal strife and media-savvy is the same territory being tread by Peter Milligan’s superb X-Force, but is handled in a much more serious and striking manner. Millar’s work is not the satirical tale Milligan has been telling, but rather, a true update and examination of how a superhero team would be handled at the turn of the new century. A valentine to Stan Lee, Jack Kirby, Don Heck, Roy Thomas, and John Buscema, Millar and his giggling cohort Bryan Hitch show that the essence of these characters remains timeless.

“Thunder” is a misnomer. The story centers not around new-age liberal hippie Thor, but on the brewing storm clouds within the psyche of Bruce Banner. Banner, still reeling from his inability to synthesize the super-soldier serum from Captain America’s blood, has become the popular whipping boy of the group – the guy who not only cannot access his superpowers to aid the team, but who cannot even do the one job he has spent his entire career investigating. Betty Ross, his estranged significant other, spends her time harping on Banner for this failure, as well as his inability to think with an eye towards the media coverage the team needs to survive.

Betty gives him another job – recruit Thor. If he does not manage, their “temporary break becomes something more permanent.” Needless to say, he and Nick Fury do not manage to recruit Thor, a new-age guru who participates in protests against the “corrupt machine” that the team represents. Refusing to work for Fury and “the people like him,” Thor sees it as his sworn duty as the Son of Odin to protect the world from the status quo. Coupled with this failure, Banner must deal with the mockery of his teammates, who dislike him and mock him behind his back. Confronted finally, in one of the book’s best scenes, with their insults, Banner snaps. Cut to New York City, where Betty Ross receives a phone call during a business dinner with Freddy Prinze, Jr. about his role in a movie about the team. It is Banner. He has injected himself with a mix of the Hulk serum and Captain America’s blood. He warns Betty to get out of New York, and then collapses. In the ambulance on the way to the hospital, the change occurs, and the team finally has an enemy to face.

Millar’s pacing is spot on, with the slow, deliberate cracking of Banner’s mind and his resort to the serum to unleash his pent up anger, rage, and sorrow resonating in the reader. It is hard not to feel bad for Banner, the oddball on a team of oddballs, saddled with the verbal berating of his peers and his own sense of failure. He misses the cathartic release of his own emotions, and it is almost hard not to cheer when he finally lets go.

Likewise, Millar’s sense of dialogue makes the book a really fun and exciting read. The verbal sparring between characters courses with energy, from the invective speech Betty gives poor Banner, the “casting-call” scene where Banner finally snaps, Thor’s condemnation of Fury and everything the team and he stands for – all these conversations have roots in reality. The bonding between Wasp and Captain America is ace, with a palpable sense of friendship forming between the two. Millar’s sense of comedic pacing shines, as well. The casting call, which degenerates into nastiness against Banner, starts off as a rather humorous and tongue-in-cheek admission of the actors on which Hitch based his character designs. Similarly, the first line the Hulk utters is the kind of insane pop-madness that comicdom has long been missing. Throughout the book, Millar uses pop-culture references that should resonate well with a mainstream audience. Millar is writing the sort of story idea for showing the audience what comics can be – big summer blockbuster fun delivered every month.

Hitch masterfully rises to Millar’s script with gorgeous and stunning art. From the cover to the final splash page, Hitch imbues these characters with the sort of energy that makes even the most mundane scene seem larger than life. Insertions of real life people are no problem for Hitch, with picture perfect illustrations of Shannon Elizabeth and Larry King finding their way into the opening sequence. Hitch, known for his ability to draw insane scenes of mass destruction occurring to well-known cityscapes cultivated during his Authority tenure, shows versatility. There is not a whole lot of action in Millar’s script, but it does not matter, because Hitch makes it all seem beautiful. With a electrifying cover and awesome Authority-esque splash page, the kicking and exploding of next month’s issue cannot come fast enough.

The Ultimates represents a synergy of word and picture that exemplifies what the comic artform is capable of – insane fun and a pure pop-thrill. Millar and Hitch have written an accessible and entertaining story that anyone, comic fan or not, can read. The Ultimates stands as the best superhero-comic book currently on the stands, and if you are not reading it, you are simply missing out on a purely fun piece of visceral storytelling. If Stan Lee and Jack Kirby were creating the team today, this is what it would be, without question. There is only one reason this book did not get perfect fives -- there would be nowhere to go when Millar and Hitch pull out the really good stuff.

ART:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

STORY:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

OVERALL:
http://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xfull.jpghttp://x-mencomics.com/xfan/images/xhalf.jpg

Buy this issue online now from X-World Comics (http://www.x-worldcomics.com/x/bstore/newbooksmain.html) and save!

King Edward III
May 4, 2002, 01:11 am
They need to get Currie and Mounts off this book immediately and beg Depuy and Neary to come back, because the art is what carries this book.

Nick Costanzo
May 4, 2002, 01:31 am
What book were you reading? This is the best art I've ever seen in a comic book!

DancinFool
May 4, 2002, 01:51 am
K.E. 3, why do I have this gnawing feeling that you're not even reading these Ultimate books, and instead are just commenting on them from the names in the credits?

I've always been easily fascinated by the art that I see in comic books, mainly because I can't even draw a simple stick figure. However, what Hitch and Currie are producing in this book (I've never seen work by either of them previously, btw) is jaw-dropping. Not only is it superbly realistic, it's incredibly well-detailed. In fact, it's some of the most detailed art that I have ever seen anywhere! Well, except for Nancy. Oh that Sluggo. Bravo, another superlative issue of Ultimates. This is one Ultimate book that definitely is going to stand out as something different from the status quo laid out in it's predecessor.

Maximus Prime
May 4, 2002, 03:30 am
great review for what i hope will be a great issue
spoiler warnings regarding banners transformations might help????

Cobiatic
May 4, 2002, 04:05 am
Bah, I really cant seem to get into this book. I usually dont go for cliche teams like the avengers and such, but I decided to give this one a chance. It appears to be just as good as you say, but I find myself skimming through it and putting it of as "something to read when im really bored". I found this ish to be pretty confusing too, but maybe thats because I really havent read any of the issues :op Oh well, hopefully Ill get inspired to read them all soon enough :) The team looks cool...I just cant seem to get turned on to it...*shrug*

King Edward III
May 4, 2002, 04:12 am
Originally posted by outlawstaar
What book were you reading? This is the best art I've ever seen in a comic book!

Go read the Authority. This is great art, of course, that's why I said it's what's carrying the book, but Currie is a terrible inker and Mounts is too dark for Hitch, Depuy gives a much better blend of colors, she's the best colorist in the biz afterall.

Originally posted by Dancin Fool
K.E. 3, why do I have this gnawing feeling that you're not even reading these Ultimate books, and instead are just commenting on them from the names in the credits?

No. I read them. I didn't say the art wasn't good(infact I don't see how you people could get anything but the exact opposite from what I wrote), I said get Depuy/Neary(who have worked with Hitch for years) and it'll be ALOT better.

I've always been easily fascinated by the art that I see in comic books, mainly because I can't even draw a simple stick figure. However, what Hitch and Currie are producing in this book (I've never seen work by either of them previously, btw) is jaw-dropping.

Ah, well see, there's your problem right there. Hitch is the best monthly artist in comics today, there's no denying it. Cassaday is the only guy who even comes close, we may have our personal preferences, but Hitch is the most realistic, by far. Go look at some of his JLA work, or his Authority work, it's amazing stuff, with Paul Neary and Laura Depuy Bryan Hitch is perfect. Here, he's still the best, but just look at characters who are in the background, sloppy inking and coloring jobs. I'm afraid it's partly due to Hitch's page pace, which doesn't give Currie and Mounts much time to complete there end of the bargain.

strangerx
May 4, 2002, 04:20 am
Well I thought that the art in the book was really good, and complemented the story nicely. I can't wait until next issue to see the team in action against the Hulk.

Erwin Rafael
May 5, 2002, 12:04 pm
Originally posted by King Edward III
They need to get Currie and Mounts off this book immediately and beg Depuy and Neary to come back, because the art is what carries this book.

c'mon, King Edward. stop comparing this to the Authority. a lot of reviewers give Currie and Mounts really good marks so far. Paul Mounts in particular is really showing us a lesson in how to color comic books...

and about your apparent hatred for Mark Millar which you have voiced everywhere else in this forum, well, i guess we can not do anything about that...

on a different note, let's say welcome to Anthony Zisa as our new Ultimates reviewer!!! thanks for picking up my "old job", ACZ :D much appreciated ;)

King Edward III
May 5, 2002, 07:29 pm
When Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch are on a super team book, it's hard NOT to compare it to the Authority. I happen to think Depuy and Neary are much better at what they do. I give reasons and examples, so you're welcome to look for yourself.

I don't think Mark Millar is a good writer, is there something wrong with that? Nobody seems to care when Rob Liefeld or Todd McFarlane is bashed at every convenient chance, and I actually give substance to my complaints.

On a positive note, the Ultimates is so far the best Ultimate book I've read and the only one which I don't despise. However, this issue had scripting flaws, as many fans have said. It was far from perfect. If the next issue is better, I'll give proper credit.

Brian Wilkinson
May 5, 2002, 07:31 pm
this is a GREAT creative team that has generated a very compelling story that has completely pulled me in. I'll be buying this one for months to come!

Anthony Zisa
May 5, 2002, 08:20 pm
Originally posted by King Edward III
I happen to think Depuy and Neary are much better at what they do. I give reasons and examples, so you're welcome to look for yourself.

I don't know why Neary's not inking Hitch (their AUTHORITY stuff was very, very nice, as was the JLA stuff), but I'm sure it's scheduling conflicts. Or, perhaps Marvel just wanted a different look for the inking.

As far as Depuy... that's not even close to feasible. She's happy at Crossgen, she's only got two non-CG projects left to do (MOS and PLANETARY), and I think she's going to be drinking the punch in Tampa for a good, long while. It would be nice to have her, of course, as she is a fantastic colorist. It's just not happening.

Originally posted by King Edward III
I don't think Mark Millar is a good writer, is there something wrong with that? Nobody seems to care when Rob Liefeld or Todd McFarlane is bashed at every convenient chance, and I actually give substance to my complaints.

Okay. Ladies, gents. Ian doesn't like Mark's work. You guys do. Let's not go back and forth for hours, because none of you will change your minds. Agree to disagree, or at least recognize you see things differently. You can all argue all you want in the ULTIMATES #4 thread in the Ultimate Marvel forum, because I don't have to moderate there.

--acz

King Edward III
May 5, 2002, 10:25 pm
Unfortunately, Marvel already asked Depuy and she declined, hence my saying "beg".

I'll shut up now, I've said all I wanted to.

Erwin Rafael
May 6, 2002, 03:14 am
Originally posted by King Edward III
When Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch are on a super team book, it's hard NOT to compare it to the Authority. I happen to think Depuy and Neary are much better at what they do. I give reasons and examples, so you're welcome to look for yourself.



fair enough. i just got the impression (at first) that it's like a "they are the best art team together and they should always be the ones paired up" thing. it's like when JoeyQ draws and Jimmy Palmiotti does not ink it, fans automatically see the art as lacking. same thing when Alan Davis does not work with Mark Farmer. but art is subjective, though, so i totally respect your opinion...

btw, K.E. III, the only issue you read was Ultimates 4? you should read issue 2. best art i have seen in Ultimates so far :D

Jacowboy
May 6, 2002, 05:18 am
What's up with that Hulk cover attached to the Review post... My copy has a Thor cover (GREAT BTW). Are there two versions or did you (Anthony) did not find the cover art and put that one instead?

Anthony Zisa
May 6, 2002, 05:32 am
Originally posted by Jacowboy
What's up with that Hulk cover attached to the Review post... My copy has a Thor cover (GREAT BTW). Are there two versions or did you (Anthony) did not find the cover art and put that one instead?

I believe the link Eric provided links to next issue's cover. Mine had Thor on it as well.

--acz

Jacowboy
May 6, 2002, 06:09 am
oh ok. Thanx. That Hulk cover looks good too I can´t wait for next issue´s battle. Im betting Hulk is gonna kick everyone´s arses pretty bad, cause you know "Hulk is the strongest there is"

King Edward III
May 6, 2002, 11:48 pm
No, I like this art just fine, infact I never EVER said I didn't like it. What I SAID was that not only did I like it, but I think this is the best art currently in comics. The worst colorist and inker couldn't ruin Hitch's work, because he's just that damn good. So please, enough with the art thing, if I'm going to stop buying this book, it won't be because of the art, that's for sure. I'm allowed my complaints.

Benjamin Ong
May 7, 2002, 01:30 am
What's this with Arabs and Chinese being labelled as terrosists?! :mad: :mad: :mad:

Anthony Zisa
May 7, 2002, 04:20 am
Originally posted by xpawn
What's this with Arabs and Chinese being labelled as terrosists?!

Umm... they weren't labeled as terrorists. They were labeled as potential spies. And it would be a more than reasonable fear within the Ultimate Universe.

If your superweapon's apartment was breached, wouldn't you think espionage is behind it? Or at least worry that it was?

--acz

Wolverine
May 8, 2002, 09:01 am
This sound rocking. I am oly getting it thissaterday. Damn. THe Ultimates is better than Ultimate X-men

gyrgatus
May 19, 2002, 02:00 am
overall the ultimates has showed great pacing, and banner turning into hulk again, just terrific! hope he beats the hell out of the ultimates before they finally get to subdue him (especially hank pym for that matter).

evil_ash_xero
May 19, 2002, 08:24 pm
I think this book is great. As for what King Edward said....well, he's right to a degree(in my opinion) The art is phenomenal, and is the best art out there right now, but Depuy was a better colorist, in my opinion. It's a little too...dull, for my tastes. I wished it was more colorful, you know? As for the inks, yeah, they're a little sloppy. It doesn't really harm the art too much, but
i've seen better. Still, it's a great book. I don't want to get a back and forth going on here, so if you like the ink and color, good for you. :)

sam m.

Pigster
May 21, 2002, 11:02 pm
I agree with King Edward III (cool username by the way) to a certain extent. I also feel the the colours are too dull and dark in this comic book. Not to say that Mounts is a bad colourist, just that it isn't compatible with Hitch's pencils in my opinion.

Hitch puts so much detail in his work but the colours seem to hide much of this. Sometimes I feel like turning on the light within the comic so I can much better see the detail.

I didn't have a problem with the first issue being so dark. I thought it went perfectly well with the whole WWII scenes. But I expected it to brighten up with the following issues.

Oh well, other than that, I really can't complain. The Ultimates have by far exceeded my expectations, I'm just waiting to see that action which is sure to come! I hope Hulk shows the team where the real power is and wipes the floor with them. :)

melt
Jun 9, 2002, 07:20 am
Originally posted by Anthony Zisa


I believe the link Eric provided links to next issue's cover. Mine had Thor on it as well.

--acz


Where can I see this link?